| 2010 to 2019 |
| 2000 to 2009 |
| 1990 to 1999 |
| 1980 to 1989 |
| 1972 to 1979 |
| 2010 Ruddigore |
| 2011 The Gondoliers |
| 2012 The Sorcerer |
| 2013 Iolanthe |
| 2014 The Pirates of Penzance |
| 2015 The Yeomen of the Guard |
| 2016 The Mikado |
| 2000 HMS Pinafore |
| 2001 The Sorcerer |
| 2002 The Gondoliers |
| 2003 Yeomen of the Guard |
| 2004 Iolanthe |
| 2005 Princess Ida |
| 2006 Pirates of Penzance |
| 2007 Mikado |
| 2008 Patience |
| 2009 HMS Pinafore |
| 1990 Pirates of Penzance |
| 1991 Princess Ida |
| 1992 The Gondoliers |
| 1993 HMS Pinafore |
| 1994 Yeomen of the Guard |
| 1995 Iolanthe |
| 1996 The Pirates of Penzance |
| 1997 Patience |
| 1998 The Mikado |
| 1999 Ruddigore |
| 1980 H.M.S Pinafore |
| 1981 Ruddigore |
| 1982 The Pirates of Penzance |
| 1983 The Gondoliers |
| 1984 Patience |
| 1985 Yeomen of the Guard |
| 1986 Iolanthe |
| 1987 The Sorcerer |
| 1988 The Mikado |
| 1989 Ruddigore |
| 1972 Trial by Jury |
| 1973 HMS Pinafore |
| 1974 Iolanthe |
| 1975 The Gondoliers |
| 1976 The Pirates of Penzance |
| 1977 The Yeomen of the Guard |
| 1978 The Mikado |
| 1979 Princess Ida |
| Current Hall of Fame |
| Past Hall of Fame |